top of page
Search

A leak and a PR misfire: Community newspaper editor’s firing reveals field’s vulnerability

Jun 10, 2024
4 min read

By Mary Kay Bean, APR


An employee leaks a company’s internal memo to a news organization. The company pinpoints the employee’s activity on its own system, and company management fires the employee for violating policy by sending the information to a competitor.


It’s fairly common practice to fire an employee for sharing internal information with outsiders. It becomes a PR problem when the leak exposes the company reportedly misrepresenting its activities to analysts and in a webcast. Media giant Gannett recently experienced this situation, which also reveals the cracks in media corporations’ support for community journalism in the U.S.


Poynter reported the leak-and-firing scenario and possible corporate missteps in May. The coverage happened after the now former editor of the Holland (Mich.) Sentinel shared information with Poynter on corporate parent company Gannett’s lack of progress in hiring additional staff for community papers.


Gannett had announced plans to hire at least 30 new reporters for outlets with one or none, but it suspended the plan in November 2023. Poynter reports Gannett’s chief content officer continued to tout the hiring plan’s successes as recently as February.


Like many employees who leak information to the press, the former editor hoped a story would force changes in the organization. Unfortunately, her firing was a change she didn’t anticipate.


Juggling Act in Tulip City: The former editor, Sarah Leach, was editing not only the Holland paper and other Gannett Michigan community papers but also responsible at some level for about 20 other papers. The outlets are spread across the Upper Midwest and northern plains states. That’s a big job to manage when you also are doing everything you can to report a critical story at home.


Leach had done excellent work for Gannett covering the political drama at the Ottawa County (Mich.) Board of Commissioners. Since early 2023, the board’s ultra-conservative faction pushed to remake county government, starting with the dismantling of the county health department. The health department seemingly was targeted for its COVID-19 enforcement actions.


Leach was nominated for a Pulitzer Prize in local reporting for her Ottawa County Board stories.


PR strays from lane: In a follow-up story, Poynter’s Rick Edmonds asked Gannett’s chief communications officer to react to his characterization of the Leach firing story. Lark-Marie Anton of Gannett went a bit too far: "Sarah has her version of the 'truth' and then there’s the narrative she is choosing to peddle to justify her actions."


Anton further emphasized management’s openness to employee inquiries and the corporation’s need to protect sensitive internal information. She should have stayed in that lane. Her words about the former employee seem bitter.


Everybody plays the fool: Each player contributed to the disservice to local journalism and has many questions to answer:

  • Gannett: They’ve taken a reputational hit, and you must recognize the irony of firing an employee for doing something they encourage editors and reporters to do every day: develop inside sources and get inside information. Why did an executive reportedly tell analysts and the public Gannett was making strides toward hiring more community journalism staff after pausing the plan? How can the Sentinel and Gannett’s other community papers continue to provide good coverage of critical local stories without enough boots on the ground?

  • Sarah Leach: While she has found free-lance work, she didn’t receive severance because Gannett deemed her situation dismissal “with cause.”  Will her actions impact her future employability? Can she keep her pledge to continue reporting on Ottawa County government without the resources of a full-time media job?  (See her statement about the situation here and a video published by The Detroit News.)

  • Poynter: Does the Poynter writer have unrealistic expectations about how an employer handles policy violations (reprimand or suspension vs. firing)? Was the potential damage to the source considered in the push for information?


PR lessons: It’s critical to keep reminding your employees about policy and the consequences for violators. This suggestion may earn some eye rolls, but it’s in everyone’s best interests to keep the information fresh. Also, PR must emphasize the critical nature of listening to staff and addressing concerns as one of the best ways to avoid both morale and PR problems. As this situation shows, the employee who feels ignored can and often will distribute externally what an organization shares internally. It’s also important to avoid letting frustration goad you into providing a media response you may regret later. It’s always best to be on your guard.


The biggest losers: Ottawa County residents may be the biggest losers. Because community journalism just doesn’t get enough corporate media funding, they may not receive the information needed to make clear judgments about local officials’ effectiveness in an election year.


It’s going to be difficult for the paper to cover the county board without the institutional knowledge of the editor who knew the background so well. Admittedly, I have a vested interest in this community paper because I own property in Ottawa County and want to know what’s going on in local and county government.


I worked for a small-town newspaper for five years and know the value of community journalism. I am saddened by this story and the stories of community papers that have folded. We are losing the local watchdogs of democracy at a staggering rate, and we all are poorer for it.


Public relations professionals also should feel concerned because community journalism is an important resource. Without it, we will find it harder to connect with target audiences.


© Mary Kay Bean, APR/Mount PR/June 10, 2024

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
3 Impactful Words: The Value of APR

by Mary Kay Bean, APR I earned my accreditation in public relations more than 25 years into my PR career. Long Wait: You may wonder why I...

 
 
 

Comments


Get in Touch and Share Your Thoughts

Thank You for Reaching Out!

© 2023 by Mount PR. All rights reserved.

bottom of page