97 Books: Community picks school library materials to stay on shelves
Updated: Apr 22, 2024
by Mary Kay Bean, APR
A South Carolina school district’s community-relations response to an activist book-ban effort provides a model response strategy for other communities.
Activist Challenge: During the 2021-22 academic year in Beaufort, South Carolina, activists took issue with 97 books then in use by the school district. They contacted the school board, harassed librarians, and threatened legal action to remove the books from district libraries and curricula.
Between July 2021 and June 2023, the nonprofit group PEN America reported 5,894 instances of school book bans across 41 states. This number includes 3,362 instances of books banned in public schools during the 2022-23 academic year, which is a 33% increase from the prior academic year.
Model Response: The Beaufort County School District responded by actively engaging the local community in determining the books’ fate. Their strategic approach can serve as a model to help school district public relations practitioners and those who advise them answer similar challenges.
Key Plan Elements: Community engagement, policies and procedures, open meeting act rules, and availability of public information were the key elements of the response.
Full-Year Public Review: The Beaufort school board heard from the public on both sides of the book banning issue. It selected community volunteers to read and review each of the 97 questioned titles in group meetings held from December 2022 to November 2023.
Review Website: The district created a dedicated website page, School Library Materials Reconsideration Information, that detailed the review process. Volunteers could apply to serve on the Library Materials Review Committee via a form on the district’s website. Criteria in an administrative regulation (Administrative Regulation IS – 38.1) were used to determine the committee’s makeup.
Guidelines Established: The 146 volunteers representing the community plus teachers and librarians were given the following guidelines for their work:
Committee meetings are conducted in accordance with the provisions of the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act, and committee members are to follow Administrative Regulation IS-38.1, Procedures for Handling Questioned or Challenged School Library Materials.
The value of the book is to be examined as a whole and the impact of an entire work considered, transcending individual words, phrases, and incidents.
Review Process: The district removed all 97 books from its shelves – most in high school libraries and four in classroom curricula -- until the volunteer committee completed its review. The committee met monthly at district facilities from December 2022 to November 2023, except in July. Committee members were instructed to read each assigned book in its entirety, work professionally with other committee members, and attend in-person meetings as needed to complete the process.
Full Transparency: Each title being considered was listed on the dedicated web page and its review status updated. Following the review, 92 of the 97 books were returned to school libraries and classrooms. Beaufort County’s Board of Education concurred with the findings of the book review committee by a 7-3 vote.
Dick Geier, Beaufort school board vice chairman, told CBS 60 Minutes’ Scott Pelley in a story that aired in March 2024, “…what we’re having a problem with is parents that want to determine what other parents’ rights are for their children to read what they want.”
Problem solved.
© Mary Kay Bean, APR
April 17, 2024
Comments